Tourism in New Zealand: are the Kiwis killing the goose that laid the golden egg with over-enthusiastic development of infrastructure?
By Robert Pimm, Globe Correspondent
Boston Globe, November 7 2004
WANAKA, New Zealand — Lewis Verduyn gestures with an oar. “To pick tea from a tea tree,” he says, “take the older growth, not the tips. You don’t want to damage the bush.”
We fan out across the riverbank and gingerly begin to gather the dark green leaves. Verduyn moors the raft, then heats river water in his Volcano, a hollow flask filled with burning twigs. For a few blissful moments, the only sounds are the crackle of the fire and the rushing of the great, green, glacier-fueled Upper Clutha River.
Near Mt Cook (Photo: PM)
We hear the jet-boat before we see it. A growl swells to a roar as the yellow and purple monster bursts around a bend in the river. We stare as the boat flashes past. How can they see anything at that speed? Then we’re alone again.
My children, Owen, 11, and Anna, 9, watch Verduyn, a wiry outdoor type with a wry sense of humor, as he whirls a pail of tea around his head.
“It must be seven times, for flavor,” he says. “We have a strainer, because even in the wilderness, you can still be sophisticated.”
We savor the refreshing brew, and our idyll is restored. Almost. Because if Verduyn and his bittersweet tea show why New Zealand is a must-see for ecotourists, that jet-boat is a symbol of how everything could turn sour.
Tourism in New Zealand is booming. In the last six years, international visitor numbers have risen 41 percent. But that success poses challenges for a country whose unique selling proposition in the global tourism market is spectacular, unspoiled nature. We found New Zealand’s outdoor activities and wildlife outstanding, but under pressure.
Akaroa, where we start our visit to New Zealand, is typical of the ecological treats the country has to offer. The harbor of this pretty seaside town is the collapsed crater of an extinct volcano, 20 miles across. This is the site of the first — and last — French settlement in New Zealand, founded in 1838. It’s also the calving ground of the rare Hector’s dolphin, the smallest dolphin species in the world.
Durelle Bingham started Akaroa Harbour Cruises with her husband, Ron, in 1985. They’ve been running dolphin trips since 1991.
“It seems to be fashionable in England to swim with dolphins before you die,” she says. “It topped the list in a survey. We’re happy it did.”
Our launch sets off across the bay, the rugged rim of the crater looming above us. The sky is grey; Owen and Anna wear two wet suits each. Our skipper tells us the aim is to let us mingle with a pod of dolphins, but we’re not to disturb or touch them, and we won’t swim with mothers or calves. Minutes later, we’re bobbing in the chill water where the crater opens into the Pacific Ocean. A mile away, the barren shore plunges into the sea.
The dolphins weigh a maximum of 105 pounds, with black and white markings and a unique, rounded dorsal fin. It’s thrilling to have them swimming near us, in pods of three to six, but hard to see beneath the choppy surface of the water. After several dips and a couple of hours, we’re back on board, exhilarated but cold, clutching mugs of hot chocolate as we head for shore.
Wildlife pops up in unexpected places in New Zealand. At the Woolstore Cafe in Oamaru, the homemade cakes are delicious and the apple juice the finest I’ve tasted. The surprise comes when proprietor Carol Burns pulls up one of the floorboards to reveal a blue penguin burrow, complete with penguin and a very fishy smell indeed.
As dusk falls, we visit the Oamaru Blue Penguin Colony nearby to watch the diminutive creatures, also known as little or fairy penguins, come ashore. Denis, our guide, says the colony started 13 years ago with a few nesting boxes in a deserted quarry. Now there are 180 boxes in an area planted with native trees and shrubs.
Denis has his work cut out, because for a long time the only animals in sight are Boris and Snugget, two resident fur seals — impressive, but not why we’re here. Just after 10 p.m., Dennis calls for silence.
“The first group of birds is off the coast now, about 100 meters out to sea,” he says.
Suddenly, the water roils with penguins. There’s a moan of excitement from the crowd, and a chorus of shushes. Then a group of 25 penguins appears, waddling up from the beach right in front of us. More appear: 21, then seven, then 30, massing as if for an attack. The penguins are in no rush. They stand at the top of the shore so long that the viewing platform starts to empty. By the time the stragglers disperse into the undergrowth, we are alone, looking out into a clear, fresh night.
Perhaps the best way to get close to nature in New Zealand is to put one foot in front of the other. At Lake Manapouri, we hire a rowing boat to cross the Waiau River and embark on the four-hour Circle Track.
At once, we are swallowed by a primeval forest. Everywhere, ferns unfold like alien seedpods. Huge fungi climb up rotting trunks. We hear the trickle of water and the cries of birds.
At the summit, we eat our packed lunch looking out over the mountains of Fiordland. A South Island robin hops up, as if to demonstrate the fearlessness of New Zealand birdlife, and sits watching us from within arm’s reach.
That evening, I meet Julia Wolfrum, a nurse from Hamburg, in the campsite kitchen. She has just completed the Kepler Trail, one of New Zealand’s Great Walks, a set of government-maintained hiking trails in the country.
“The isolation and silence are magic,” Wolfrum says. “When you’re hiking, all alone, and it’s getting dark, you imagine things. It’s like a fairy tale sometimes. The nature makes you feel like a child again.”
Up the road in Queenstown, nature is in full flight.
Queenstown advertises itself as “The Adventure Capital of the World,” where you can bungy jump, heli-ski, jet-boat, or sky-dive. The confines of the modest town can no longer accommodate the throng of thrill-seekers. Soaring mountains still fringe the lake, but condos are creeping along the shore, a snake of traffic clogs the road into town, and Louis Vuitton has set up shop along with Global Culture, a clothes store.
If your idea of a holiday is a seething mass of cars and people, topped off by a cacophony of helicopters, Queenstown may be for you. Otherwise, it serves only as a warning of the perils of overdevelopment.
“Queenstown used to be nice, but it’s a mess, now,” Verduyn says, as we continue our trip down the Upper Clutha. “We don’t want to get like that.”
He points out a bunker-like private dwelling atop a bluff, and shakes his head.
“It was a disaster to put that building in there,” he says. “People from all over the world are coming here seeking a wilderness, a sanctuary. The worst-case scenario is that we damage the environment, which brings people to New Zealand in the first place.”
For more about tourism in New Zealand, see my piece Wildlife in New Zealand: the penguin’s distressed, we’d better go. Or read why Barcelona has similar problems…
P.S. you can sample more fresh, original writing on this site via my 5 pleasure paths. If you enjoy it please follow me on Facebook Or you can join my mailing list.
15 responses
This article offers a very thoughtful perspective on tourism in New Zealand and its impact on the economy. I really liked how the writer explained both the opportunities and challenges connected with rapid tourism growth. The examples used in the article make the topic easy to understand for readers from different backgrounds. It also encourages people to think about sustainable travel and protecting natural beauty for future generations. Overall, this was an informative and engaging read that provided valuable insights into modern tourism trends and development.
I enjoyed reading this article because it explains the tourism situation in New Zealand in a clear and interesting way. The writer shared important points about how tourism supports businesses, jobs, and local communities while also creating environmental concerns. The balance between economic growth and sustainability was discussed very well throughout the article. I also appreciated the simple writing style because it keeps readers engaged from beginning to end. Thank you for sharing such useful information and thoughtful opinions on this important subject.
This was a very well-written article about tourism and its influence on New Zealand’s economy and society. I found the discussion about balancing tourism growth with environmental protection especially meaningful. Many destinations around the world face similar issues, so the topic feels relevant globally. The article is informative without being too complicated, which makes it enjoyable for readers of all ages. I appreciate the effort put into explaining the subject with clarity and honesty. Looking forward to reading more insightful content like this in the future.
The article provides a great overview of the tourism industry in New Zealand and the benefits it brings to the country. I liked how the author highlighted not only the economic advantages but also the challenges connected with overcrowding and environmental pressure. The writing style is professional yet easy to follow, making the content very engaging. It encourages readers to think responsibly about travel and sustainability. Overall, this was a balanced and informative article that gave me a deeper understanding of tourism issues in beautiful destinations.
I really enjoyed this article because it presents an honest discussion about tourism in New Zealand. The author explained how tourism can create jobs and strengthen local businesses while also affecting the environment and infrastructure. I found the examples and arguments very realistic and relatable. The article is organized clearly, making it simple for readers to understand the key message. It also reminds travelers to respect local culture and nature when visiting popular destinations. Thank you for sharing such thoughtful and educational content with your audience today.
This article was both informative and interesting to read from beginning to end. The discussion about tourism’s impact on New Zealand’s economy and environment was presented in a balanced and thoughtful way. I appreciated how the writer focused on sustainability and responsible tourism rather than only financial benefits. The article encourages readers to think more carefully about how travel affects local communities and natural resources. The writing style is smooth, clear, and engaging, which made the topic enjoyable to learn about. Excellent work on this meaningful article.
I found this article very insightful because it explains the complex relationship between tourism and sustainability in New Zealand. The author did an excellent job describing how tourism contributes to economic growth while also creating environmental challenges. I especially liked the focus on long-term planning and protecting natural attractions for future generations. The content is easy to understand and written in a professional yet friendly tone. Articles like this are important because they encourage awareness and responsible travel choices among readers and tourists around the world.
This was an excellent article that shared valuable information about tourism in New Zealand and its overall effects on society. The writer explained the positive economic impact very clearly while also discussing the importance of preserving the environment. I appreciated the balanced perspective because it showed both sides of the issue instead of focusing on only one viewpoint. The article is informative, well-structured, and easy to read for a wide audience. Thank you for publishing such thoughtful content on an important and globally relevant topic today.
I really liked the way this article explained the tourism industry and its influence on New Zealand’s development. The points about economic benefits, environmental protection, and community well-being were all presented thoughtfully. It is refreshing to read an article that discusses tourism in a realistic and balanced way. The writing style kept me interested throughout the entire piece, and I learned several new things from it. This kind of content is valuable because it encourages readers to think more responsibly about travel and sustainable tourism practices.
The article provides a meaningful discussion about tourism and its growing role in New Zealand’s economy. I enjoyed how the writer explained both the opportunities and the risks connected with increased tourism activities. The focus on sustainability and environmental responsibility was especially important and relevant in today’s world. The article is written in a simple yet engaging manner, making it easy for readers to connect with the ideas presented. Overall, this was a thoughtful and informative piece that offered useful insights into modern tourism challenges and solutions.
This article was very informative and gave a clear understanding of how tourism affects New Zealand in different ways. I liked how the writer explored both the economic advantages and the environmental concerns connected with tourism growth. The discussion felt balanced and realistic, which made the article more trustworthy and engaging. The writing style is smooth and easy to follow, even for readers who are not experts on the topic. Thank you for sharing such detailed and thought-provoking content about sustainable tourism and responsible travel practices today.
I enjoyed reading this article because it presents important ideas about tourism in a thoughtful and balanced way. The writer clearly explained how tourism supports economic growth while also creating challenges related to environmental protection and overcrowding. I especially appreciated the focus on sustainability and long-term planning for future generations. The article is written in a simple and engaging style that makes the information easy to understand. Overall, this was an excellent piece of writing that encourages readers to think more deeply about tourism and its wider impact.
This article gives readers a strong understanding of tourism in New Zealand and the issues connected with its rapid growth. I appreciated how the writer discussed the benefits of tourism while also acknowledging the environmental and social challenges involved. The article encourages responsible tourism and highlights the importance of preserving natural beauty. The writing style is clear, informative, and enjoyable to read from start to finish. Thank you for sharing such valuable insights and raising awareness about sustainable tourism and community responsibility in modern travel industries worldwide.
I found this article very engaging because it presents tourism in New Zealand from multiple perspectives. The author explained the economic importance of tourism while also discussing environmental concerns and the need for sustainable practices. The examples and explanations were easy to follow, making the article suitable for many different readers. I also appreciated the balanced tone because it avoids exaggeration and focuses on realistic issues. Overall, this was an informative and well-written article that encourages people to think carefully about tourism and its long-term effects on society.
This was a thoughtful and well-structured article about tourism and its impact on New Zealand. I liked how the writer explored both the positive contributions of tourism and the challenges it creates for local communities and the environment. The discussion about sustainability was especially important and relevant today. The article is written in a clear and engaging way that keeps readers interested throughout the entire piece. Thank you for sharing such informative content and encouraging awareness about responsible tourism and environmental protection for future generations around the world.